Recently someone asked me what I thought about the new WHO report which classified red meat and processed meats as carcinogens – cancer causing agents – together with substances like alcohol, asbestos, tobacco smoke, mineral oils, estrogen, ionizing radiation and diesel engine exhaust. People tend to read headlines and often the sensationalism of saying a hamburger or roast beef sandwich is just as deadly as smoking can throw people into a panic. But is that the whole truth here?
First of all there’s a difference between red meat and processed meats. Processed meats are defined as being “transformed through salting, curing, fermentation, smoking or other processes to enhance flavor or improve preservation.” Red meat is considered to be “muscle meat such as beef, veal, pork, lamb and mutton.” While the processed meats were classified as definitely carcinogenic, the study said red meat is “probably” carcinogenic and that was in relation to colorectal cancer in particular.
Processing and cooking at high temperatures is what produces certain carcinogens in the meat. That being said the other issue which wasn’t addressed is quality of the meat. I eat red meat. However, I am careful to choose organic, grass fed and finished meat. I believe it comes down to quality. If you eat CAFO beef you are also eating hormones, antibiotics and grains that they are fed.
Putting processed meats in a class equal to smoking cigarettes and red meat just slightly below that is unfair in my opinion. From my understanding, this was not a truly controlled study as the participants did not have similar living conditions, were not in isolation, where everyone involved was eating exactly the same foods, exercising the same, getting the same amount of sleep, and being exposed or not being exposed to other potential carcinogens.
In actuality, properly raised red meat has numerous health benefits and when you choose pasture-raised, it’s actually healthier than white meat in many ways. So what’s my recommendation: I would choose the best quality processed meat you can find (100% natural, from grass-fed without added chemicals) and only have that occasionally and choose only organic, pasture raised (grass-fed and finished) red meat as part of your healthy meals.
Do you eat red meat? What do you think of the new WHO guidelines?
Want to see more articles like this? Subscribe to this blog (just click on “Follow”) and get each new post delivered to your email or feed reader. To follow me and get even more tips on how to live your life in 3-D as well as getting exclusive information on giveaways and special offers, be sure to like me on Facebook, sign up for my FREE weekly No-Nonsense Nutrition Report, follow me on Pinterest and Twitter!
Make gradual changes. Boost health, vitality and energy. Become your best YOU.
Yes I eat red meat. Sometimes grass fed and sometimes not. I’m not going to live in fear about things in this world that could kill me. Instead I’m going to trust God to sanctify what I eat so it will nourish me and not harm me.
Have a Victorious Day! Marianne
Sent via phone so please excuse typos and brevity.
Marianne it is never my intention to put people in fear only to educate and inform. That being said, trusting God to sanctify our food is foundational. I do that with everything I put in my mouth, including supplements. I know God alone is the Healer and I look to Him and trust Him, but I also believe in making the healthiest choices available.
Great post topic! I think that the WHO guidelines discuss something that has already been known but may not have been common knowledge to the general public. In addition to potential effects of processed meat, I think the bigger issue, which you slightly touched on, is HOW red meat is cooked (i.e. charring and blackening). Although I agree that the quality of meat is important, the method of cooking is the bigger factor in the cause of these carcinogens in meat.
Excellent point and very true – the quality and the method of cooking are the most critical issues here.
Ann, after being a vegetarian for a decade I now eat pastured, organic beef. When I dropped gluten and added beef and organic other meats my waste size shrank. I actually prefer beef to chicken. According to the book. Eating for Your Blood Type, I do better with beef. I wondered what you thought about organic beef jerky.
Isn’t that amazing Debbie! I think organic beef jerky is a great snack!